Seeking Sister Wife: Garrick Wants Another Wife — Tells Dannielle She Must Marry Her!

Twist after twist seems to be the new go for Seeking Sister Wife cast member Garrick and his family. Garrick lives with his two partners, Dannielle and Lorrana, in a plural family dynamic. For this to happen, Garrick even had to divorce Dannielle. With the season finale now released, Garrick seems to be pushing things even further. Garrick hinted that the family may soon add a new wife.

But the complication that comes with it left viewers stunned, and Dannielle in disbelief. This unexpected move comes at a somewhat messy time for the Merrifields. The family has been juggling a new marriage, a newborn baby, and legal troubles recently. But why did Garrick bring up this major decision now? And how did Dannielle respond when she learned what he expected from her this time? Keep reading to find out.

Seeking Sister Wife: Garrick’s Legal Trouble Adds Tension to His Plural Family Plan

It’s been an eventful month to say the least for the Seeking Sister Wife followers, who follow the Merrifield family. The household has been under stress, especially after Garrick and his second wife, Lorrana, welcomed their baby girl, Sarah. This change in their lives came right before Garrick’s arrest, who was taken into custody for domestic violence. Fans couldn’t help but ask questions about what was happening inside the family home. According to police records, officers responded to a domestic violence report involving Garrick and Lorrana.

Documents later confirmed that the argument escalated when Garrick grabbed her phone and refused to let her contact her family in Brazil. When she tried to call the police, he still withheld her phone and allegedly threatened to contact ICE. The affidavit states that Lorrana, unfamiliar with the U.S. legal system, became terrified and tried searching online for help until Garrick shut off the Wi-Fi. Fans online said that they were relieved that former sister wives like Roberta and Natalia were no longer involved.

Seeking Sister Wife: Garrick Tells Dannielle She Must Marry The New Wife

As the finale started, Garrick sat down with his partners and, to their surprise, announced that the family was preparing to look for a third wife. After legally marrying Lorrana in 2024, he insisted that expanding the family was part of their spiritual calling. But the biggest shock came when he told Dannielle she would need to legally marry the new wife if the woman came from another country. Garrick explained that because Lorrana is not yet a U.S. citizen, he and she cannot divorce anytime soon without slowing her immigration process.

He argued that the “best option” would be for Dannielle to be the one to legally marry the new person so she could immigrate. Dannielle couldn’t hold back her reaction, as she appeared confused and emotional. She admitted she had no idea she would need to do this in the future. Meanwhile, Lorrana also shared her discomfort with the whole thing. With the new marriage, the baby, and the cultural adjustments, she was already feeling overwhelmed.

She told Garrick she wasn’t ready to bring in another wife, especially while she was struggling with limited time with him. Garrick listened but didn’t budge from his beliefs. He reiterated his thoughts by saying they needed to remain open to “God’s plan.” Fans, however, were quick to call out what they called manipulation. They also felt Garrick had a pattern of targeting women with language barriers or limited support systems. For the latest Seeking Sister Wife tea, stay tuned to TV Season & Spoilers.