90 Day Fiance New Star Shea’s Ex Wife Has A Criminal History — Get The Arrest Details Here!

In the newest season of 90 Day Fiance, Shea’s ex-wife Nicole makes an appearance. In the season description, Shea’s relationship with Annabelle is strained by Nicole’s disruptions. Shea also called Nicole jealous of his new relationship. However, the ex-wife’s checkered past recently came to light, making her seem anything but innocent.

Shea and Nicole got into a little argument in the latest season, showing how incompatible they are. Even though Nicole points accusatory fingers at Shea, she also has a reputation for trouble. With her past criminal record coming to light, she cannot keep blaming Shea for his past. So, what led to Nicole ending up in handcuffs? What were her criminal charges? Keep reading for the full story.

90 Day Fiance: All About Shea and Ex-wife Nicole’s Relationship

A new teaser for Season 12 of 90 Day Fiance showed a heated moment between Shea and his ex-wife, Nicole. Shea is now in a relationship with Annabelle and opened up about why his marriage to Nicole ended after only four weeks. He explained that they fought often and realized they were not compatible. Annabelle admitted she knows very little about Shea’s past marriage, and now Nicole feels she deserves to hear the full story.

Nicole warned that Annabelle should know the “dirty” details about Shea before making a lifelong commitment. Shea then accused Nicole of trying to ruin his relationship during a group trip. Nicole fired back, claiming Shea was unfaithful and got with Annabelle while legally married to Nicole. She believed Shea had two-timed his wife with Annabelle. The 54-year-old realtor, however, strongly denied the claims, saying Nicole is only trying to upset him.

90 Day Fiance: Nicole’s Alleged Criminal Past Explodes Online – Shocking Rap Sheet Below!

90 Day Fiance’s new star, Shea McGuire’s ex-wife, Nicole, appeared on a sneak peek. She accused Shea of infidelity, but fans can now see she isn’t squeaky clean either. A famous blogger, kikiandkibbitz, posted Nicole’s mugshots along with her arrest information. Nicole allegedly trespassed in 2024, leading upto her being thrown behind bars for second-degree criminal trespassing charges. But that’s not all. Her criminal past did not end there; her arrest sheet listed multiple other charges.

Apart from trespassing, the charges included public intoxication, possession of an alcoholic beverage in a motor vehicle, and marijuana, along with drug paraphernalia. More serious charges included a second-degree disorderly conduct charge and a fourth-degree assault charge. The assault charge did not have any visible injury. Further, in 2025, she was arrested for driving with a suspended DUI license. So Nicole now has repeat offender fame, making fans talk about her.

When Nicole’s past was exposed, fans questioned how TLC allowed her on their show. A few fans also wondered if the network ever conducts a background check before putting them in infront of its cameras. Some viewers are now wondering if Nicole’s past will become part of the storyline later in the season. Now, with Shea’s arrest history along with Nicole’s, it seems they are cut from the same cloth. Further, did Nicole’s arrest clash with Shea’s realtor fame, leading to their split? Only time will tell. For more updates, follow TV Season & Spoilers.