Suddenly Amish: Fans Aren’t Ready For Emma & James’ Cousin-C€st!

For all those who have been busy for the past few days, here’s a Suddenly Amish update that is blowing up the fandom. Emma and James are third cousins, and a recent clip clearly hints at them dating. Now, fans cannot keep calm and immediately turn to Reddit to discuss their cringeworthy romance.

Things seem even worse when fans realized that Emma and James take rules quite seriously. Emma loves the monitored Amish dating, and James loves to stick to rules. How are fans taking the consin-cest? Read all about it below.

Suddenly Amish: Fandom Shocked After New Clip Drops Emma And James H00k Up

Amish members Emma and James are definitely hooking up. In a recent clip, things got super sus between them. A nighttime clip of the show shows Emma knocking on James’ door. He comes out with a bare torso and a covered lower body. He goes over to Emma’s room and knocks. Emma tells him to come in, and he goes in. This comes right after James says they have never hooked up.

Fans can tell how different their body language is in the confessional. For starters, Emma softly asks James if he would ever date him. He says he doesn’t know. Emma also adds that she truly respects them and that he has taught her so much. Additionally, the clip includes raw footage of them, with very hands-on body language in the kitchen. The whole thing becomes a bit cringey since they are third cousins.

Suddenly Amish: Fans Discuss ‘The Emma-James Cousin-Cest’

The fandom is cringing hard with the recently revealed alleged romance between James and Emma. Suddenly Amish fans discussed this in detail on Reddit. One fan posted a still from the clip of James holding Emma from behind with a caption, “TLC editors really said: ‘Let’s add some spice … sir, that’s a cousin.” Now, fans cannot stop talking about the most shocking thing that they saw on the show.

Fans know Emma and James are third cousins. So the hooking-up part might not be illegal or even biologically okay, but it is still making fans side-eye. One fan commented on the thread, “Spice!? He was whole-ass nakkidd going into the bathroom with his cousin. Yikes.” Another said, “When he went into the kitchen and grabbed her by the waist, I had to cover my eyes.” Another shocked fan commented that they thought Emma and James were a married couple helping others in the community diversify.

The fact that they were related by blood and allegedly got intimate made fans barf. Another fan commented that James is creeping on his younger cousin, Emma. Also, when Emma said he had taught her many things, what exactly did he teach her? Fans are also speculating that if James does a lot of things he isn’t meant to be doing, like helping Kendra call her mom and then hugging her.

Also, given that they are so strict about rules, it is frustrating to see them break them. Another fan mentioned that they make everyone uncomfortable. Others find it amusing that the editors have been hiding this from viewers for so long, as it doesn’t appear to be a one-time thing. For more Suddenly Amish updates, follow TV Season & Spoilers.